Site • RSS • Apple PodcastsDescription (podcaster-provided):
Condensing recent work in metaphysics and the philosophy of science down to what matters. Hosted by Dr Sam Kimpton-Nye, research associate on the MetaScience project (ERC, Horizon 2020, grant agreement No 771509; www.metascience.xyz) at the Unversity of Bristol. Music: NaturesEye from Pixabay. Art: Francesca SmithThemes and summary (AI-generated based on podcaster-provided show and episode descriptions):
➤ Metaphysics and philosophy of science paper discussions • modality (possibility/necessity, possible worlds, Quine) • laws of nature, Humeanism, grounding • quantum measurement • naturalized metaphysics methodology • biology/biochemistry (function, individuality, realization) • AI singularity safety • panpsychism • time, symmetry, explanationThis podcast focuses on contemporary metaphysics and philosophy of science, using recent journal articles and books as springboards for explaining live debates and the arguments driving them. Episodes typically center on a single piece of scholarly work, clarifying the author’s core theses, the motivations behind them, and the most important objections or alternatives. Some instalments take the form of extended conversations with the researchers themselves, giving additional context about methodological choices and how philosophical questions connect to scientific practice.
A major throughline is modality: what it is for something to be possible or necessary, how (or whether) modal claims can be explained via possible-worlds frameworks, and whether modal truths might be grounded in conventions, norms, or other non-metaphysical sources. Closely related discussions cover counterfactual and “counterpossible” reasoning, and the status of modal skepticism and anti-realism.
Another recurring theme is the metaphysics of science, especially laws of nature and explanation. The podcast examines competing pictures of laws—such as Humean approaches versus “governing” conceptions—and what those pictures imply for explanation, symmetry principles, and puzzles in physics. Quantum mechanics appears as a case study for how metaphysical stances interact with foundational problems, including questions about measurement and how to interpret scientific theories.
The show also ranges into ontology and grounding, including debates about substance, realism, supervenience, theoretical virtues in metaphysical theorizing, and persistent worries about disagreement and methodology in the field. Alongside physics-oriented material, there is sustained attention to philosophy of biology: accounts of biological function, biochemical realization, evolutionary explanation, and issues about biological individuality that can intersect with ethical questions.
Overall, the content is aimed at readers interested in how rigorous metaphysical tools are applied to science and how scientific developments, in turn, constrain or motivate metaphysical theories.
| Episodes: |
|
37: "Why Being Necessary Really Is Not the Same As Being Not Possibly Not", Dana Goswick 2024-Jun-04 9 minutes |
|
36: "The Singularity: A Philosophical Analysis", David Chalmers 2023-Jul-19 23 minutes |
|
35: "There is no measurement problem for Humeans", Chris Dorst 2023-Jul-08 16 minutes |
|
34: "The Limits of Modality", Sam Cowling 2023-Jan-19 13 minutes |
|
33: "Biochemical Functions", Francesca Bellazzi (deep dive featuring the author!) 2022-Dec-22 37 minutes |
|
32: "Substance", Donnchadh O'Conaill (deep dive featuring the author!) 2022-Aug-23 73 minutes |
|
31: "Biological Individuality and the Foetus Problem", Will Morgan (deep dive featuring the author!) 2022-Jul-26 45 minutes |
|
30: “How Skeptical is Quine’s “Modal Skepticism”?”, John Divers 2022-Jul-05 14 minutes |
|
Ep. 29: "Modal Conventionalism", Ross Cameron 2022-Apr-06 9 minutes |
|
Ep. 28: "Panpsychism", Thomas Nagel (CM classic!) 2022-Mar-16 9 minutes |
|
Ep. 27: “Modal dispositionalism and necessary perfect masks”, Barbara Vetter and Ralf Busse 2022-Feb-02 11 minutes |
|
Ep. 26: "An Apology for Naturalized Metaphysics", James Ladyman (deep dive featuring the author!) 2022-Jan-26 49 minutes |
|
Ep. 25 "The Governing Conception of Laws", Nina Emery (deep dive featuring the author!) 2021-Dec-22 48 minutes |
|
Ep. 24: “Going Beyond the Fundamental: Feminism in Contemporary Metaphysics”, Elizabeth Barnes 2021-Dec-15 9 minutes |
|
Ep. 23: "Governing Without a Fundamental Direction of Time", Chen and Goldstein 2021-Dec-01 11 minutes |
|
Ep. 22: "Aristotelian Supervenience", John Heil 2021-Nov-03 11 minutes |
|
Episode 21: "Causal Content and Global Laws: Grounding Modality in Experimental Practice", Jenann Ismael 2021-Oct-27 10 minutes |
|
Episode 20: "Disagreement in Metaphysics", Timothy WIlliamson 2021-Oct-20 12 minutes |
|
Episode 19: "Realism Without Parochialism", Phillip Bricker 2021-Oct-13 10 minutes |
|
Episode 18: "Metaphysics After Carnap: the Ghost Who Walks?", Huw Price 2021-Oct-06 13 minutes |
|
Episode 17: "Social kinds are essentially mind-dependent", Rebecca Mason 2021-Sep-29 11 minutes |
|
Episode 16: "Calculus and counterpossibles in science", Brian McLoone 2021-Sep-22 11 minutes |
|
Episode 15: "The rationality of metaphysics", E.J. Lowe 2021-Sep-15 12 minutes |
|
Episode 14: "Where Do You Get Your Protein? Or: Biochemical Realization", Tuomas Tahko (deep dive featuring the author!) 2021-Sep-08 40 minutes |
|
Episode 13: "Norms and Modality", Amie Thomasson 2021-Sep-01 9 minutes |
|
Episode 12: "What Everyone Should Say about Symmetries (and How Humeans Get to Say It)", Michael Townsen Hicks (deep dive featuring the author!) 2021-Aug-25 54 minutes |
|
Episode 11: “Nomothetic Explanation and Humeanism about Laws of Nature”, Harjit Bhogal 2021-Aug-18 12 minutes |
|
Episode 10: "Realism and the Absence of Value", Shamik Dasgupta 2021-Aug-11 14 minutes |
|
Episode 9: "Megarian Variable Actualism", Toby Friend (deep dive featuring the author!) 2021-Aug-04 27 minutes |
|
Episode 8: "Sideways music", Ned Markosian 2021-Jul-28 9 minutes |
|
Episode 7: "The Ground Between the Gaps", Jonathan Schaffer 2021-Jul-21 11 minutes |
|
Episode 6: "Conceptualizing causal powers: activity, capacity, essence, necessitation", Ruth Groff 2021-Jul-14 10 minutes |
|
Episode 5: "There Are No Ahistorical Theories of Function", Justin Garson 2021-Jul-07 8 minutes |
|
Episode 4: "Troubles with Theoretical Virtues: Resisting Theoretical Utility Arguments in Metaphysics", Otávio Bueno and Scott Shalkowski 2021-Jul-07 9 minutes |
|
Episode 3: "Ramseyan Humility", David Lewis 2021-Jul-07 8 minutes |
|
Episode 2: "Fundamental Powers, Evolved Powers, and Mental Powers", Alexander Bird; "Evolved Powers, Artefact Powers, and Dispositional Explanations", Barbara Vetter 2021-Jul-07 16 minutes |
|
Episode 1: "How scientific models can explain", Alisa Bokulich 2021-Jul-07 10 minutes |
|
Episode 0: Introducing Condensed Matter 2021-Jul-07 2 minutes |